As a former dean of students and nonprofit consultant, I’ve seen firsthand how the right goals can transform an organization’s impact. But I’ve also witnessed well-intentioned teams struggle when their goals don’t align with their mission or consider the human element of their work.
During my years working with independent schools and nonprofits, I discovered that the most successful organizations weren’t just setting SMART goals—they were setting goals with HEART. Today, I’ll share the framework that has helped my clients create meaningful change while staying true to their mission.
Why Traditional Goal Setting Falls Short in Nonprofits
Let’s be honest: most of us have sat through strategic planning sessions that produced impressive-sounding goals that gathered dust on a shelf. I remember one particularly frustrating afternoon spent crafting what seemed like perfect objectives for a charter school’s expansion. The goals looked great on paper, but something was missing—the connection to the real students and families we served.
That experience taught me that nonprofit goals need something more than just structure. They need soul.
The SMART+HEART Framework: Where Structure Meets Purpose
The SMART framework (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) gives us a solid foundation. But for nonprofits, we need to add HEART:
- Human-centered: Centers the communities we serve
- Empathetic: Considers the emotional impact
- Adaptable: Flexes with changing needs
- Relationship-building: Strengthens community connections
- Transformative: Creates lasting positive change
Putting It Into Practice
Here’s how this looks in real life. Instead of setting a goal like “Increase program participation by 25% in Q3,” we might frame it as:
“Engage 25 more families in our after-school program by September through personalized outreach and program adaptations based on community feedback, ensuring each family feels welcomed and supported in their participation.”
Notice the difference? The second version maintains the SMART elements while incorporating the human element that makes our work meaningful.
The Mission Impact Matrix: Aligning Goals with Purpose
One tool I’ve found invaluable is the Mission Impact Matrix. Here’s how to use it:
- List your potential goals
- Give each goal a Mission Alignment rating (1-100)
- Does this initiative drive create forward progress for the organization?
- Give each goal a Resource Requirement rating (1-100)
- Consider all of the resources it might take to implement this work
- Plot them on two axes
- Mission Alignment (low to high)
- Resource Requirements (low to high)
- Prioritize high-alignment, achievable-resource initiatives
I recently used this with a nonprofit transitioning from middle to high school programs. By plotting various expansion initiatives on the matrix, we identified which goals would make the biggest impact while staying within our resource constraints.
Engaging Stakeholders in Goal Setting
Remember that strategic planning session I mentioned earlier? Its biggest flaw was missing key voices. Here’s what I’ve learned about inclusive goal setting:
Essential Voices to Include:
- Program participants and their families
- Front-line staff
- Board members
- Community partners
- Volunteers
Making Engagement Meaningful:
- Host focused listening sessions
- Use anonymous feedback tools
- Create multiple channels for input
- Follow up to show how input shaped goals
The Resource Reality Check
As someone who’s helped organizations expand programs and navigate transitions, I can’t stress enough the importance of resource planning. Before finalizing any goal, ask:
- What’s the true financial cost?
- Do we have the right staff capacity?
- What training or support is needed?
- Are our systems adequate?
- What partnerships could help?
Putting It All Together: Your Goal-Setting Roadmap
Here’s your step-by-step guide to creating impactful goals:
- Review Your Mission: Start with your “why”
- Gather Input: Engage key stakeholders
- Apply SMART+HEART: Use the framework to shape goals
- Check Resources: Be realistic about needs
- Create Timeline: Set clear milestones
- Plan Review Points: Schedule regular check-ins
Setting strategic goals isn’t a one-time exercise—it’s an ongoing journey of learning and adaptation. As you implement these frameworks, remember that perfection isn’t the goal. Progress is.
I’d love to hear about your experiences with goal setting in your organization. What challenges have you faced? What strategies have worked well? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Need support in becoming an authentic leader?
Bridget Johnson has helped many people discover the best versions of themselves. Reach out today!
OR
Visit The Deans’ Roundtable
The premier community for deans of students and student life professionals, the Deans’ Roundtable offers countless opportunities for growth, and a chance for you to connect, learn, and share knowledge.