When I started working at a nonprofit organization, I quickly realized the importance of a cohesive and aligned team. About three months into my role, I started to understand just how critical it was for leadership to be on the same page to drive results. What I learned during this time was that without clear alignment, communication, and psychological safety, even the most talented group of people could struggle to make progress. Decisions were delayed, tasks became ambiguous, and frustration crept in. It wasn’t a matter of competence—it was about a lack of clarity in our roles and processes, and the absence of a safe space for everyone to fully participate.
Psychological safety became the key lesson for me. It’s vital that each team member feels they have the freedom to speak up, challenge ideas, and take ownership of their work without the fear of being judged or dismissed. This wasn’t just about getting things done; it was about fostering an environment where people could show up as their best selves. And when leadership is aligned and feels psychologically safe, that’s when the magic happens—people collaborate, ideas flow, and real progress is made.
The Challenge of Building Leadership Teams
Building an effective leadership team is never easy, and it’s only becoming more complicated as organizations face rapid change, diverse stakeholder demands, and the need to stay agile while holding everyone accountable. The traditional top-down approach often leaves untapped potential within teams, while overly flat structures can lead to confusion and inefficiency.
I’ve seen this play out in various contexts—whether it’s in independent schools, nonprofit organizations, or corporate settings. Despite having skilled people, the team can’t function cohesively if roles and responsibilities aren’t clearly defined. Teams need a clear framework that enables everyone to contribute without feeling ignored or overwhelmed. The question often becomes: How can leaders collaborate effectively while making sure all voices are heard and decisions are made efficiently? The answer lies in creating a system that clarifies decision-making authority while promoting collaboration.
Clarifying Decision-Making Authority and Accountability
One of the most important aspects of a functioning leadership team is a clear decision-making framework. When there’s confusion around who is responsible for what, nothing gets done. By defining decision-making roles, you can prevent unnecessary delays and ambiguity, creating an environment where accountability is clear, and each person knows their role in the process.
The RACI Framework for Leadership Decisions
A tool I find helpful in clarifying decision-making is the RACI matrix. Here’s how it works:
- Responsible: Who will do the work?
- Accountable: Who has the final authority to make decisions?
- Consulted: Who provides input before decisions are made?
- Informed: Who needs to be kept updated on the outcome?
For each major decision in your organization, define these roles. This ensures that no one person bears the weight of decision-making alone, and everyone understands how they contribute to the process.
Creating Decision Authority Levels
A common pitfall is assuming that consensus is required for every decision. However, this can slow progress. Instead, create decision authority levels:
- Level 1: Individual leader decides and informs the team.
- Level 2: Individual leader decides after consulting with team members.
- Level 3: Team collaborates to reach consensus.
- Level 4: Senior leader decides after team input.
- Level 5: Board or external authority required.
This framework allows decisions to be made efficiently while ensuring the right input is sought at the right time.
Building Collaborative Processes That Work
Collaboration is essential, but it needs structure. Without a clear process, collaboration can devolve into unproductive discussions. Creating systems that ensure everyone’s voice is heard while moving the team toward action is key to maintaining momentum.
The Three-Phase Collaboration Model
Here’s a three-phase model I’ve found effective for decision-making:
- Divergent Thinking (Expand): Encourage everyone to share their ideas, suspending judgment and exploring all possibilities. (30-40% of decision-making time)
- Convergent Analysis (Evaluate): Assess the options against established criteria, weighing risks and benefits, and consider differing perspectives. (40-50% of decision-making time)
- Decision and Action (Commit): Make the decision and communicate the rationale clearly, then outline the implementation steps and accountability. (10-20% of decision-making time)
This model ensures that all perspectives are considered but avoids the trap of overthinking and stagnation.
Regular Check-In Rhythms
Keeping everyone aligned is crucial for maintaining forward momentum. Set up consistent communication patterns, such as:
- Weekly tactical meetings: Focus on short-term priorities and roadblocks.
- Monthly strategic sessions: Dive deeper into long-term goals and progress.
- Quarterly leadership retreats: Reflect on the team’s effectiveness and re-align on organizational direction.
These regular touchpoints ensure that the leadership team stays aligned and focused on both immediate tasks and broader goals.
Developing Leadership Capacity Through Intentional Growth
A great leadership team is not just about the here and now; it’s also about developing future leaders. By fostering a culture of mentoring and providing opportunities for growth, you ensure that leadership talent continues to thrive.
The Mentoring Web Approach
Instead of traditional one-on-one mentoring, build a web of relationships:
- Senior leaders mentor multiple emerging leaders.
- Emerging leaders receive mentoring from different senior leaders.
- Cross-functional mentoring ensures exposure to a variety of perspectives.
By creating this web, you break down silos and ensure that leadership development is a shared responsibility across the organization.
Stretch Assignment Strategy
Provide growth opportunities that push team members beyond their comfort zones, such as:
- Leading cross-departmental projects
- Representing the organization at external events
- Facilitating strategic planning sessions
- Shadowing board meetings or client interactions
These stretch assignments help leaders gain experience while also addressing organizational needs.
Balancing Autonomy with Institutional Alignment
As you empower leaders within your organization, it’s important to ensure their actions remain aligned with the institution’s mission. Too much autonomy can result in misalignment, while too little can stifle creativity and initiative.
The Alignment Framework
Create clear boundaries within which leaders can operate freely:
- Mission Guardrails: Core values and principles that guide all decisions.
- Strategic Priorities: 3-5 focus areas for the current period.
- Resource Parameters: Constraints on budget and staffing.
- Stakeholder Commitments: Promises made to key stakeholders.
These guardrails ensure that while leaders have the freedom to innovate, their actions align with the overall goals of the organization.
Regular Alignment Check-ins
Schedule quarterly alignment sessions where leaders can present how their departmental goals connect to institutional priorities, the decisions they’ve made, and the support they need from others.
Questions for Reflection
As you assess the effectiveness of your own leadership team, reflect on these key questions:
- When was the last time every team member actively contributed to an important decision?
- How often do your team’s meetings result in clear decisions that are followed through?
- Do your team members feel psychologically safe to voice concerns and ideas?
- How are emerging leaders being supported and developed within your team?
- How well is your leadership team aligned with the organization’s mission and strategic priorities?
Moving Forward Together
Building an effective leadership team requires intentional effort, but it’s worth it. By setting clear decision-making frameworks, fostering psychological safety, and investing in the growth of your leaders, you create an environment where everyone can contribute their best work. The result? A stronger, more cohesive team that can make better decisions, drive innovation, and achieve organizational success.
Effective leadership is an ongoing process, and by nurturing it, you’ll build a team capable of meeting challenges, supporting each other, and advancing your organization’s mission with confidence.
About the Author: Bridget Johnson, a former associate executive director, has worked in education for much of her career, primarily in independent schools and nonprofits. As a former dean of students and director of special programs, she has helped schools expand their offerings while maintaining their core values. Bridget now works as an independent consultant helping educational institutions implement data-driven strategies that support their unique missions.
Need support in becoming an authentic leader?
Bridget Johnson has helped many people discover the best versions of themselves. Reach out today!
OR
Visit The Deans’ Roundtable
The premier community for deans of students and student life professionals, the Deans’ Roundtable offers countless opportunities for growth, and a chance for you to connect, learn, and share knowledge.